29/10/2026
A HARNESS DOESN'T TRAIN YOUR DOG NOT TO PULL!
Here's something I see almost daily.
Dog pulls on the lead. Owner gets frustrated. Someone recommends a harness.
Problem solved?
Not quite.
Now you simply have a dog dragging you down the road in a harness instead of a collar!
You've changed the equipment. You haven't changed the behaviour.
Let's talk about harnesses, collars and why I choose different equipment for different purposes.
🔴 FRONT-CLIP HARNESS
These are often marketed as no-pull solutions. But have you considered HOW they work?
When the dog pulls, the front attachment redirects the dog's body, potentially creating uneven pressure and altering its natural movement.
I'm not interested in relying on mechanical restriction to teach a dog to walk politely.
🔴 HARNESSES THAT RESTRICT SHOULDER MOVEMENT
I'm referring to designs with a horizontal strap running across the front of the shoulders.
Depending on their design and fit, these can interfere with the dog's natural stride.
A dog's shoulders are attached to the trunk primarily through muscles rather than a conventional bony joint. Allowing natural shoulder movement matters.
I prefer equipment that works WITH the dog's anatomy rather than restricting it.
SO WHY DO I PREFER A COLLAR?
For everyday lead walking, obedience training and controlled outings, my preference is generally a properly fitted collar.
Why?
Because I want to communicate with the dog, not physically manage its entire body.
A collar allows me to give clear, subtle lead guidance and teach the dog to respond to light pressure, rather than constantly leaning into the equipment.
I want a dog that understands:
- Where its handler is.
- How to respond to lead guidance.
- That pulling doesn't earn forward movement.
- That walking WITH me is more rewarding than dragging me behind it.
I also prefer a collar when working on engagement, position changes, loose-lead walking and obedience exercises.
For dogs that are physically suited to collar work, it gives me the communication I want without having to rely on a harness to redirect their entire body.
BUT HERE'S AN IMPORTANT DISTINCTION!
A collar is NOT an excuse to jerk, yank, choke or drag a dog around by its neck.
And I certainly wouldn't use one to restrain a dog that is repeatedly lunging at full force.
If a dog is constantly hitting the end of the lead, we need to address the training, environment and safety rather than simply applying more pressure.
Dogs with certain medical conditions, neck or airway concerns, and some other individual needs may be better suited to a harness.
Good training means choosing equipment appropriate for the individual dog.
WHEN WOULD I CHOOSE A HARNESS?
Absolutely! Harnesses have their place.
For tracking, certain working disciplines, pulling activities and appropriate conditioning exercises, I WANT equipment designed for those activities.
In those situations, I prefer a correctly fitted, non-restrictive harness that allows natural shoulder movement and distributes pressure appropriately across the dog's chest.
I may also use a harness as an activity cue, helping the dog distinguish between different types of work.
Different equipment. Different expectations.
The equipment should suit the job, not replace the training.
NOW LET'S ADDRESS THE REAL PROBLEM...
Your dog doesn't pull because you haven't bought the right harness.
Your dog pulls because, somewhere along the way, pulling has become a successful strategy.
Think about it.
🐾 Dog pulls towards a smell. You follow. Dog gets to sniff.
🐾 Dog drags you towards another dog. You allow the greeting.
🐾 Dog jumps for attention. You eventually give in.
What has the dog learnt?
That persistence works!
Every time an unwanted behaviour successfully gets the dog what it wants, you risk strengthening that behaviour.
This is why I put so much emphasis on teaching dogs what TO DO, rather than simply trying to prevent what we DON'T want.
Teach your dog to respond to light lead pressure.
Reward engagement.
Build communication.
Set clear boundaries.
Be consistent about when forward movement is earned.
And most importantly, stop allowing pulling to be the most successful way for your dog to get somewhere!
My philosophy is simple:
I don't want a dog that walks nicely ONLY because a piece of equipment physically prevents it from doing otherwise.
I want a dog that has actually LEARNT how to walk with its handler.
A harness is a tool.
A collar is a tool.
NEITHER ONE IS A SUBSTITUTE FOR TRAINING!
🐾 CK9 COACH DOG TRAINING
Boundaries, not bullying. Rewards AND rules. Training, not shortcuts.