Caputo Brothers Creamery

Caputo Brothers Creamery Makers of hand-crafted, traditional, authentic, Italian cheeses and cultured milk products. Products Caputo Brothers Creamery is leading the Mozza-revolution!

We make artisan cheeses in the traditional Italian style, developed through years of study and training with master cheesemakers in Italy. This means we use no vinegar or citric acid in our production and all of our cheeses are naturally cultured. We are committed to exclusively sourcing our milk from local, family dairy farms. Our goal is to pay a premium for the milk they produce to create a mor

e sustainable, local dairy economy. In turn, these dairies produce a higher quality, cleaner milk, that allows us to produce a higher quality cheese. All of our farm partners are Animal-Welfare Approved, providing non-GMO feed with access to pasture when available.

Skip the green beer and celebrate St. Patrick's Day the right way... with a week of FREE Beer Cheese! 🍻🧀For this week on...
03/17/2026

Skip the green beer and celebrate St. Patrick's Day the right way... with a week of FREE Beer Cheese! 🍻🧀

For this week only, we are helping you "fill your six-pack." Buy 2 lbs of our Beer cheese, and the 3rd pound is on us!

Our website doesn't have magic powers, so you must add all 3 pounds to your cart. The cost of the third pound will magically disappear at checkout! 🌈✨

Happy π day! The masterpiece is officially in progress! 🍕✨Our curbside space is getting a major upgrade with our brand-n...
03/14/2026

Happy π day!

The masterpiece is officially in progress! 🍕✨
Our curbside space is getting a major upgrade with our brand-new Pizza Box Wall, and we want YOUR shop represented. Our dream is to feature every single partner who uses our cheese—from the legendary slice shops to the local hidden gems.
To celebrate the launch of the wall (and the magic of the π), for TODAY only we’re giving you 31.4% OFF our heavy hitters:
🧀 Gouda
🧀 Fior di Pizza
🧀 Fresh Mozzarella
Don’t see your box up there yet? We haven't forgotten about our non-delivery friends! DM us directly so we can coordinate getting your branding on the wall of fame. Let’s build this masterpiece together! 📦🤝🍕


03/12/2026

La Passeggiata—Italian for “the evening stroll”—is a new dinner series with Curata Travel and LUCA restaurant in Lancaster, PA which brings the spirit of our...

🍕🍕🍕
03/12/2026

🍕🍕🍕

The Sicilian Margherita will be a staple menu item at the new A Slice of New York Squared!!

Sourdough
Bianco Di Napoli organic tomato’s
Caputo Brothers Creamery Fior Di Latte
Corto Olive Oil
Fresh Basil
Parm

03/09/2026

Meet one of our night shift workers, Spencer!

03/09/2026

Meet one of our night shift workers, Spencer!

Join Dave & Rynn Caputo this June on a very special trip...to Croatia! While our cheese business and tours grew out of D...
03/09/2026

Join Dave & Rynn Caputo this June on a very special trip...to Croatia! While our cheese business and tours grew out of Dave's Italian background (and our love for all things Italy!), did you know that he also has Croatian heritage?

So this summer we've chartered a beautiful yacht and the Caputos will be leading this tour as we sail and island hop down the Croatian coast. Explore beautiful seaside villages, swim and play in the crystal-clear sea, and learn all about local dishes and traditions!

https://curatatravel.com/pages/cruising-croatia-i

If you know Rynn, you know she lives for the sun & the sea, so cruising along the Croatian coastline checks all the boxe...
02/26/2026

If you know Rynn, you know she lives for the sun & the sea, so cruising along the Croatian coastline checks all the boxes. Join Rynn AND Dave this June for a specially curated week-long cruise aboard our private yacht! Crystal clear water, delicious meals, sun-drenched swim stops, charming villages, and waterfalls await!
https://curatatravel.com/pages/cruising-croatia-i

02/25/2026

They’re a package deal! 🧀

Just gonna hang this photo here...
02/20/2026

Just gonna hang this photo here...

Address

245 N Main Street
Spring Grove, PA
17362

Opening Hours

Monday 9:30am - 4:30pm
Tuesday 9:30am - 4:30pm
Wednesday 9:30am - 4:30pm
Thursday 9:30am - 4:30pm
Friday 9:30am - 4:30pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Caputo Brothers Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Our Story

We're cultured & so is our cheese! We're one of the only cheesemakers producing a cultured cheese curd that can be used to stretch mozz, burrata, and other pasta filata cheeses. A family-owned cheesemaking business, with a retail shop (open M-F, 9a.m.-5p.m.)