10/06/2026
What is a Commercial Breeder?
In writing this, I figure I am going to get flack from certain people, mainly about the subject matter in general. Over the years, the idea of being a “breeder” has been put in a bad light. It doesn’t seem to matter what kind of breeding you are doing, you are the scum of the earth in the eyes of most people. Propaganda ploys from HSUS, PETA, and ASPCA, showing animals kept in deplorable conditions play on the hearts and emotions of so many people. I am not saying these kinds of places are not out there; in fact, quite the contrary. You can get sub par, terrible breeders in all types of breeding: hobby, show, and commercial breeders, not to mention the unethical, unlicensed back yard breeders that are out there, that most people do not know about.
I wanted to write this in an educated way rather than a rant on a facebook post. After all, I do have a master’s degree, so I am capable of doing so. This is going to come out in a lot of steps over the course of several weeks here on my page. I obviously do not expect everyone to agree, but very few people ever get to hear the side of a commercial breeder. They assume we are automatically bad. To be honest, that is like saying all teachers are bad because your child had a bad experience with one, or that all doctors are bad because yours had terrible bedside manner and wouldn’t listen to you. There are bad apples in every batch, it doesn’t mean every apple in the orchard is bad!
Over the next few weeks, I am going to talk about commercial breeding, what goes into it on a day to day basis, the paperwork side, the sales side, the dealing with customers, and the regulations commercial breeders have to follow. Keep in mind, this will be coming from a commercial breeder in Missouri, so other regulations in different states may vary slightly to significantly. This is also going to come from the point of view of a dog breeder. There are several other animal species out there that have their own sets of regulations, and since I have no knowledge of them, I will not be speaking on them.
Today, I think it is important to start by talking about what a commercial breeder is. You are not going to hear me use the word “puppy mill” after this moment because I truly do not believe in that term. I believe there are good and bad, ethical and unethical, and reputable and unreputable breeders in types of breeding. Research to find a breeder is key in your search for a puppy. You have to decide what you want and what you need for your home.
Commercial dog breeders are a person or a business that breeds and sells dogs for the purpose of pets and makes money from selling the offspring. This is a basic definition, but it is a pretty good summary of what a commercial dog breeder is. Some commercial dog breeders are a one man show, such as mine. While other commercial breeders are a whole family affair, or take on employees to make sure their animals are taken care of. This means I have to keep my numbers low and only have a manageable number of animals. That is different from person to person. To me there is no set rule on a number being too large. It largely depends on breed. I, personally, would think a kennel of 10 Golden Retrievers would be a lot for one person, but a kennel of 20 Chihuahuas would be manageable for someone who likes small breeds. I think it is important to never judge a breeder on the number of animals they have because you do not know what is going on behind the scenes to take care of the animals. A person with one dog can also treat that dog badly whereas a person or business can give 20 dogs the best care available.
Making money is part of that definition, but I do not for the life of me understand why that is a bad thing. In any profession you do, you make money. Beef and milk cow producers sell their calves and milk. Guess what, they make money. Sheep and goat farmers sell offspring, wool, and milk. They make money. A commercial dog breeder provides a puppy to people who want pets, why shouldn’t they be able to charge something for what they have done? Why shouldn’t they make money, too?
Some people may not know this and others may but there is a branch of the USDA that specifically over the regulation of breeding animals. Keep in mind, this license is only needed for commercial breeders that have more than 4 intact females used for breeding, if you sell to pet brokers or pet stores, or if you ship puppies either by ground or by air. My kennel is not a USDA licensed kennel. The reason is that I do not ship puppies. People either come to me to pick them up, or I take the puppy to them, sometimes by car and sometimes by plane(me or my husband actually get on the plane or I meet the person buying the puppy at the airport, and they take it with them. The puppies are not in cargo, they are in the cabin with someone). As long as I or my husband do the delivery, we are free from USDA regulations. People will not agree with this, but I have talked to my inspectors about this, and they have told me on many occasions that USDA is not a requirement for me. I am not going to go into details about USDA as I do not have the license and do not want to spread misinformation.
Also, some states have a branch of the Department of Agriculture that are specifically over the regulations of breeding animals. Missouri is one of those states, not only does it have regulations over commercial breeders, but it also regulates boarding kennels, pet stores, shelters, rescues, pounds, and dealers. If you have more than 3 intact females used for breeding in the state of Missouri, you are required to be licensed. The only exemption to this rule, that I am aware of, is a hobby breeder that has fewer than 10 intact females and has proof that they showed at least one of their dogs within the last 365 days.
Next week, I am going to get more into the Missouri State regulations so we can go through what all having and maintaining a license entails.
Again, this will be taboo to some of you, it is something that needs to be said. We are not bad people just because we breed dogs for the pet market. We aren’t bad people because we do this for a living. There is so much we go through that a lay person does not even begin to understand, yet they make judgements upon us like they know everything there is. That is why I want this to be broken down, piece by piece, and maybe, you will think a little differently of us and what we do.