Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc- Equine Sanctuary

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc-  Equine Sanctuary Our rescue is currently full and only open to emergency animal control cases. please call 502-424-4987 for more information.

Misfit Toys Rescue Division is full service 501c3 equine rescue/sanctuary/retraining facility for problem horses, specializing in saddlebreds with behavioral issues. We will, however, help place your horses into homes if you can no longer keep them.

10/16/2026

Happy Frihay! Hope everyone had a great week! Thought I would share a video of our girl Lucy doing her job so beautifully at Trinity Farm with Mary Lynn and her crew! Roland, Sunny, and Diva are there, too! They are all doing well and thriving.

It's easy to get disheartened when there are no donations and no encouragement coming in and everything seems dark and hopeless. Then, someone sends a video like this and it reminds me why we do this.

Lucy was here for eight years before she found someone who would appreciate her. Sure, it costs money to house these horses. But wouldn't you rather rebuild a horse , their skills, trust, and confidence? Be a safety net to pick her up if needed? Because we had to do that, four times, for Lucy. It has been worth every moment and every penny spent.

There are 32 other permanent residents here who need support. Some have monthly sponsors, but they do not cover all their costs. We need help. I understand that times are rough right now for everyone, so even liking, commenting, and sharing posts helps. We are monetized on both the rescue and my personal account. You don't even need to physically share the post. Just copying the link indicates to the system it's been shared.

If anyone is able to help the rescue monetarily. we are drowning and could really use the help this week. I need to redirect my personal funds to pay for my taxes and insurance this week, so there is zero that I can donate myself. Thank you in advance for any assistance provided!

10/07/2026

Huge thank you to Audrey for her $25 donation today! Greatly appreciated maam

Equine Rescue Network once posted: “We rescue horses not people.” 🤔 🤔 🤔 How do you interpret this? We see this in vivid ...
10/07/2026

Equine Rescue Network once posted: “We rescue horses not people.” 🤔 🤔 🤔
How do you interpret this?

We see this in vivid black & white. We expect horse owners, whether for pleasure or business, to act with integrity & compassion.

- No 1 Worst Excuse that horse rescue nonprofits hear every day of the week:
I impulsively bought a horse online from a trader/KB and it isn’t the fairytale unicorn I expected it to be. Now I expect a Rescue to jump at the chance to take it. Oops, if you don’t have the experience or funds for extensive veterinary and/or retraining expenses, think twice next time. Or better yet, consider adoption aka rescue with training wheels. What were you possibly thinking when you became a rescue dupe of an online equine extortion scam?

- Your riding horse ages out, or becomes injured. Retire it on your dime, or euthanize it.
- You can’t afford a new horse w/o ditching your old horse. Don’t get a new horse.
- Or the variation of ditching an old horse by going on social media with a compassionate post about needing a companion horse home for my lovely unridable horse. Heck no & shame on you - Pay for its retirement.
- You expect horse rescue nonprofits to rescue you from your bad choices or bad planning. Get ready for the chorus of No’s that you deserve.
- My parents left me a pair of bonded senior horses who have never lived anywhere else, so I expect a rescue to come get them. Both unkind to the horses, and unrealistic for the rescue.
- We don’t have control over breeders & horse gambling ‘sports’ who dump their horses (often bred back broodmares). Once slaughter export becomes unlawful, they will be forced to act responsibly in breeding with nowhere left to cull/discard horses.

Thank you for this ultra important reality check.

https://www.facebook.com/share/1GPNav6LvD/?mibextid=wwXI

We receive requests daily from horse owners who want to surrender their horse. We are part of a vast network of equine rescues that sprung up from the hearts of people who saw a problem and wanted to help. But we can't do it alone, and we were not established to just take every owner's horse. This is difficult for some to hear, and I am sorry. We are asked every day to take in horses. MOST of the are choices, not crises.
So of course are financial constraints, and I think everyone reading has faced those at some time. Here are some of the messages we receive;
-"We are downsizing and hope you will retire our horses" (Translation; 'we don't have the money, or want to spend our money retiring our own horses, and hope you will do it for us')
-"I can't afford the horse since he can't be ridden" ('Translation; 'I could afford him if he could be ridden but my desire to ride comes first, so now I don't want to pay for him')
-"He has medical costs that are too expensive, I need a horse that costs less" (Translation; 'I can't really afford a horse, I won't pay for a 'Pre-Purchase Exam', and want to get rid of this one so I can get another'... OH this is sometimes followed by 'Can I trade mine in for one of yours that rides?)
-"I have cancer, and need to place my horse" (this one used to really get to us, until we learned about a group chat where someone advised another person to tell us they 'had cancer' and we would say yes... so it's unfortunate that we are now cynical about even that reason. Usually this is one of the first situations above)
-"The owner died and I am helping to find a home for the horses" (another situation we nearly fell for, but when I looked for the obituary, there was none. Turns out the neighbor wanted the horses gone, so just lied to us about the 'living status' of the owner)
-"This horse can't be used anymore" (Translation; "I thought you loved horses and would retire it, isn't that what you do?")
-"But my horse would be so happy there!" (Translation; "I am hoping that 'stroking your ego' will work, because I don't want to make the changes necessary for my horse to be as happy here as he would be at your place, and if you say 'yes' that saves me a lot of money'... this is also usually one of the first scenarios above)
-"My relative died and I inherited a horse; can I send it to you?" (This one is truly tough, if the owner really died, and the Executor of the Estate really didn't know a horse was in the picture. But often the horse is a senior with issues, or the horse is several states away, we can best help with advice only)
-"If you take my horse I will leave you lots of money in my Will later" (This one has yet to come true, we won't hold our breath)

And I can't tell you HOW MANY TIMES we have been promised supporting funds, and none came. Even this year.

There is often a long story attached to the above scenarios, as to why this person is not 'really' responsible for the situation, they were lied to etc etc, they are the victim, and how they are trying to 'do the right thing'. And sometimes that is true. Sometimes they are good humans in a spot. Of course from our perspective, the right thing, most of the time, is to KEEP YOUR HORSE. And sometimes we get through to people, but often we do not... and we understand that horse is losing their home.
And that hurts, for the horse. Even if a home is lacking, it's still 'home'.

The problem for us is, someone else's 'need' does not create space or funds here. So even if we believe and empathize, we can't help. This is painful for us, and we always offer advice. And often the advice is to consider euthanasia at home, where the horse has been happy.

We receive more requests tan anyone could EVER fulfill. We usually must say no.
It is simply a question of available space and available funds. Our care is not free for us to provide and donations are tough to come by.

Whenever we say no, we offer suggestions. We try to help. But I remember what a DVM said once, she said "I cannot care more about the horse than the owner does"... and that is something we struggle with. We do care about each of the horses above, and seeing their photos makes it harder. We empathize with the change that horse is facing. We simply cannot say yes to every horse, nor is it always even the right decision for every horse. Some are best served by humane euthanasia at home, where they have been happy. Many owners don't want that answer, but we give it anyway. Some get angry, try to say that we only want 'adoptable' horses, or horses with a 'dowry', or insult us some other way. And it hurts but it doesn't change our answer. Of course a dowry helps, because horses cost money to live. Our horses cost between $6k-$16k each, with the average being $8,500 per horse per year, soup to nuts. That is less than many boarding barns, and it includes every expenditure here, from new gravel to truck insurance to prescriptions to vet care, and everything in between.

So yes, it's serious, heavy business.
This is why EDUCATION matters so very much.
Helping horse owners understand the nature of their horse, and the availability, or lack thereof, of 'free retirement' for horses. No one is likely to love your horse more than you (present company excepted!). But we are not the solution for most horses. We are the beacon, we hope, of what is possible, and we are here for a very few that suffered the worst answer, and were dumped without protection.

We hope that the above stories end well, as the result of a more educated owner making a better choice. And we will keep answering the phone and emails to try assist.
It's not always the journey we thought it would be!
But for 109 equines, this is home.

Thanks for sharing, and caring. YOU make the difference.

I had an entire update post made and it went P**F into FB land. So alas, here I am with the new post and update! Finn is...
10/05/2026

I had an entire update post made and it went P**F into FB land.

So alas, here I am with the new post and update!

Finn is recuperating well and the vet said based on his physical appearance and improvement after a week was remarkable with just a simple refeeding program. What does that mean? They just weren't feeding him. He is getting food here again and has gained at least 150 lbs in the past few weeks. Slow and steady wins the race. We covered his vet bill.

Attorneys to recuperate the three TN horses and and PA horse have issued lawsuits and warrants for animal cruelty and theft, respectively. We covered that, too! It's a lot of money but oh well! We promised these horses we would be there for life, and we mean it!

We are $1400 behind on last months hay, I tried to make it up with extra roofing and porch building work, but we were unable to complete it prior to month end due to weather. :(

We received another $720 in hay yesterday that I need to pay for Wednesday and we have $1075 coming Saturday as well. Yee HAW! 🤩

If you haven't noticed:

I LOVE GETTING HAY.

Love Watching the horses eat the hay.

I even love cleaning the hay that they p**p out.

I do not enjoy paying for all the hay myself (jk IDGAF 😜 but my wonderful husband is being beyond tired of it and he deserves to not be stressed to the point of a heart attack at the ripe old age of 50 and I told him I would ask for help). . So this is the help we need, folks!

You don't have to donate. I don't actually want your money, I want Metas money! but I may need it temporarily until meta starts paying me more for my posts, with all gratitude to those who donate to the rescue. I need to do better posting more often, and when you see our posts and upcoming reels, just push all the buttons and leave a comment more than six words when you see our shtuff.
It's free and only takes a couple seconds and pushes my posts out to other people who aren't as sick of my s**t as you guys are, see what I'm saying? Then Meta can pay the rescue. Zuck can afford it.

Anyway here's an updated photo of Finn! Linx in comments per usual!

MTRD is a 501c3 equine rescue in good standing, with a platinum seal of transparency from GuideStar every year since we have begun. I may need to upload this year's financials to the website though, and will do that shortly!Thanks for your support my friends!

10/05/2026

Hey guys! Shoofy McTenderloin the Third, here. I was rescued off the euthanasia list at a Kentucky shelter at the last minute with the help of our friend, who is the staff veterinarian there! I just want to clarify some things. 🥳✌️

When I post fundraising posts, it doesn't necessarily mean I want your money. I want Metas money. So even if you can't donate, please like, comment, share, and favorite our posts! That gets us from asking you for money and getting Zuckerberg to help us pay for the horses instead. Thanks everyone!

And you can donate too. In the meantime 😂

Misfit Toys Rescue Division is full service 501c3 equine rescue/sanctuary/retraining facility for problem horses, specializing in saddlebreds with behavioral issues.

Just kidding. Sorta. Not really 😂
09/19/2026

Just kidding. Sorta. Not really 😂

This sight brings me to my knees with gratitude every time. Not just for the donors who make their happiness a daily occ...
09/19/2026

This sight brings me to my knees with gratitude every time. Not just for the donors who make their happiness a daily occurrence. But seeing them, eating with no worries, after rehabbing each and every one back from the brink of death feels really nice.

Every horse in this picture went from being mentally and physically fried to live their best lives in a herd with other horses and (mostly) only positive human engagement.

They are safe here. Nobody can hurt them. Their tummies are full, before ours at times, but it all makes me pretty damn happy.

Their happiness is what it's all about! Yay for good hay and good horses!

Misfithorsetoys.org

Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc-  Equine Sanctuary is looking for several donor levels and types for current and upcomi...
09/12/2026

Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc- Equine Sanctuary is looking for several donor levels and types for current and upcoming fundraisers!

$35/month gets free intro cookbook and monthly updates on their sponsored horse

$100/month full sponsorship- you cover this horses basic necessities for the month. For most horses, that is their basic free choice hay and grain twice a day. You choose between T-shirt and cookbook for entry gift.

$300/Dragons legacy sponsor. We specialize in elderly and infirmed horses, so a lot of ours will have a higher caloric need just based on age alone. These horses, like Dragon, are receiving hospice care and are not expected to get any better. But we are going to make the time count while they have it!

My favorite fundraiser is when everyone who likes the page donates one dollar each. It's sort of like doing the wave at a concert. It starts with one person's small action and turns into a big social action at the end, and when regular people get together, we can do extraordinary things to change the ejr

Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc- Equine Sanctuary is a 501c3 equine rescue and sanctuary committed to providing elderly and mentally defunct horses with a safe and loving place to retire 🫪🤩❤️ and has had a platinum seal of transparency from GuideStar every year since we opened. All donations and sizes count and are appreciated!

We would love to take a moment for gratitude this morning. We couldn't do this extremely heavy and heart breaking work w...
09/07/2026

We would love to take a moment for gratitude this morning. We couldn't do this extremely heavy and heart breaking work without the support of our family and friends.

Today, we went to send s Huge thank you to Laura R for sending dewormers and treats for all of her misfit "kids" that she sponsors every month. Our sassy pony, Cliff, and our two blind horses, Elton and Kota, are extremely spoiled, have revolving outfits and fly masks, and are now the pickiest blind horses on the planet thanks to their Auntie Laura!

08/30/2026

If I never do anything else in life, as long as I have made life easier for these animals, I will consider myself a success.

Featured: Rosie, 15 year old Arabian mare, has been in our sanctuary care since 2017. She is sponsored by the Bosworth family. And we could not be more grateful. We love you, Rosie and the Bosworth fam!

Address

4725 U.S. 150
Palmyra, IN
47164

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 5pm
Wednesday 11am - 5pm
Thursday 11am - 5pm
Friday 11am - 5pm
Saturday 11am - 2pm

Telephone

(502) 424-4987

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc- Equine Sanctuary posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc- Equine Sanctuary:

Shortcuts

Share