07/28/2026
In our current dog training culture, every dog is an insecure, nervous, fearful wreck who only engages in unwanted, unhealthy behavior because they’re lacking confidence.
In other words, every dog is a freaked out, unstable victim who’s only in need of loving support, cheering on, warm and fuzzy challenges, and zero negative consequences.
And while there are lots of messy dogs, and indeed many who aren’t the most confident, this wildly lopsided focus on confidence building over consequence sharing is probably the biggest obstacle to dogs actually finding a more healthy, balanced, behavior issue-free life.
But of course that belief doesn’t appeal to the countless humans who are desperate to be dysfunctionally gentle, pathologically kind, emotionally selfish, forever caretakers for their surrogate children which they wish to keep, messy, struggling, and dependent.
And while that may sound incredibly harsh, I don’t say this to be nasty—I say it because I see it everywhere. Go scroll IG, TikTok, and Facebook, and what you’ll find are countless versions of the Devouring Mother—with all genders participating.
Dogs made into perpetual fearful, unstable victims which are only served via ultra complex and ultra infective positive-only/force-free “enrichment programs”, “counter-conditioning protocols”, “threshold panicked hyper-management/avoidance”, and of course the de rigueur “confidence building exercises”.
What you won’t find is a wildly simple concept: sharing negative consequences which the dog finds valuable enough to actually stop unwanted, problem behaviors. The reactivity towards other dogs; the barking at strangers, cars, bikes etc; the over the top territorial responses to guests at the door, the whining, barking, tantrumming in the crate… and on and on.
Instead of being crystal clear with your dog as to what is and what isn’t appropriate, and then allowing them to develop appropriate emotional responses once a neutral mindset has been obtained (regardless of where the behavior was coming from), you’ll get all of the fancy, “sophisticated”, virtuous sounding and feeling training protocols that will “foster more confidence”, and then magically the deeply patterned unwanted, and unhealthy behavior will simply disappear.
Nope. It won’t. Because your messy, or just ill-behaved dog doesn’t need more confidence, it needs more clarity as to what are and aren’t appropriate responses, period.
But when our dogs are perpetual fearful infants in need of only our shielding protection from the scary world (and the confidence from us to face it), we find dogs stuck in a perpetual cycle of engaging in unwanted, and unhealthy behavior… with these behaviors viewed only as insecurity and fear, and only helped with something that has no ability to provide what it promises.
PS, I’m not saying a more confident dog isn’t something to strive for, I’m saying that how we view our dogs and how we go about creating confidence is rarely aligned with reality or what’s best for them.