08/22/2026
Force-Free dog trainers, and inconvenient truths…
I recently came across this post from Terrierman (follow him on Facebook for some outstanding posts on common sense dog training!). In his full post he walks the reader through esteemed force-free figurehead, and author of “Don’t Shoot The Dog” Karen Pryor’s actual life with her own Border Terrier.
For all of her persuasive arguments about the value and effectiveness of force-free training, apparently, and in her own words, she was unable to 1/ keep her Border Terrier in her yard without using a high voltage invisible electric fence, and 2/ was unable to ever have her Border Terrier off-leash. It was always on a leash or longline—because otherwise it would run off.
This of course is a bit troublesome if you’re one of the force-free advocates who claim that anything that can be achieved via balanced training can also be achieved with force-free methods.
When your methodology’s god is unable to keep her own dog in her yard without an electric shock from a fence, or allow her own dog the freedom to ever be off-leash, even with years of force-free training… it should make the devotees rather nervous, and it should make those contemplating the force-free path for their own dogs… do some extra deep contemplation.
There’s a reason I go on and on about this stuff. It’s not because I’m deranged or obsessed. It’s simply because I know the truth, and I know what you, the unsuspecting owner is being told is the truth… and they are very much not the same.
The question you should ask yourself is: “Self, how come the god of force-free training had to use punishment to create the behavioral effect she desired with her own dog? And self, why couldn’t she train her own dog to be off-leash reliable when countless balanced trainers achieve this goal daily, extremely easily, and reliably?”
Some good questions.
Thanks again to Terrierman. Go read his full post on Karen—it’s quite the revealing read.