03/05/2026
Skepticism Debunked
In the past thirty-eight years I’ve had many conversations about how exactly obedience training helps a dog understand good behavior.
One family came to class with a rather wild four-month -old Siberian Husky. She was cute, energetic, and dominant. The woman was distraught and hopeful class would help. The man doubted. He told me this class was the biggest waste of his money ever and that nothing was going to help that pup behave.
I began class telling them we were going to teach the dog to ‘sit’ and not get up even if we bounced a tennis ball, and we would have it accomplished by the end of that first class. He shook his head. Then he crossed his arms, got this resolute look on his face, and said, “I tell you what, if you can make that dog sit in the middle of the room and not get up even when you go outside and walk the whole way around this building, I won’t ever complain again about how much I paid for class.”
I did and he didn’t. :)
As for my clients’ questions, they are right. Teaching a dog to sit for a treat does NOT teach him good manners or behavior. I am actually not a fan of treat training. I suggest giving treats whenever you wish and do make your dog sit before giving the treat. But do NOT give him a treat each time he sits.
Obedience training not applied into everyday life is about as useful as a gas grill on your porch that has no propane.
It is not in teaching your dog the commands that he learns to behave, it is in applying them. He should always SIT when you give him a treat. But go much further than that. If the only commands your dog ever learned were ‘sit’ and ‘done’ you could have a well-mannered pet. (I feel you would be doing your dog’s intelligence and abilities a disservice if that was all you taught him.) But I digress. When you tell him to ‘sit’ he should do so immediately and not stop until you release him saying ‘okay you’re done.’ Once he understands the command, then apply it.
Make him ‘sit’: when company comes in, when company leaves, before he goes outside, before he comes inside, before he eats, while you eat, when he needs to calm down, to place him in a ‘timeout’ for punishment, at the veterinarian’s, at street corners, when you meet other people or dogs on walks, while you wipe muddy feet off, when he is right under your feet as you do housework, when he is begging, and so on.
And, that’s just the short list! Add a few more basic commands like down, heel, come, stay, stand, leave it, drop it, turn away, and back it up to his repertoire. Then you have a wealth of options to use in teaching your dog proper behavior. Those are only the basic obedience commands. Our dogs can easily learn 100 or more commands.
Give it a try. Teach your dog the commands, and use them in your regular routine with him. In the end you, like my client, will not complain again and your best friend will be even better!
Send a message to learn more