06/15/2026
When I switched my e-collar to a clicker.
Crossing over is something I am very open about. I donât try to hide it, and I like to let people know I can relate to them in many ways because of my cross over.
After a long time of feeling like punishment wasnât the answer, the final straw was lots of time working with a âbalanced trainerâ using the e-collar for excitement reactivity toward other dogs. My dogâs emotions were shutting down. I was told that I needed to keep turning up the level on my remote slowly til he looked away from my friends dog, then I reward. This attempt of suppression caused other issues and eventually his reactivity worsened. We started to rely on punishment way more than reinforcers, he wasnât listening, he wasnât paying attention to me, he was out in a situation where he was over threshold, and the added emotional pressure of the ecollar stimulation plus his emotions from seeing another dog would mean he started to react bigger when he saw a dog, because he started associating the sight of a dog with me pressing the button. I was told to was teaching him what not to do and what to do, but it was really teaching him the presence of another dog walking by was something to be concerned and nervous about because it meant the collar stimulation would occur.
Well, whatâs wrong with teaching a dog what to do as well as what *not* to do? Well because it *isnât* teaching what not to do. As we have known for decades now, shown over with studies ever since B.F. Skinners punished work in 1937, we have seen that behavioral change due to punishment does not equate to learning. We know this because when the punishment is removed, the behavior doesnât stick.
(More in comments)