10/22/2026
When we ask a horse to do something and don’t receive the response we were hoping for, we might assume that we simply haven’t made ourselves clear enough. That may be true, but clarity doesn’t necessarily mean more intensity. We need to be careful that turning up the volume doesn’t become our only strategy, because we may simply be asking the same question again, only louder.
A stronger aid might be appropriate, but increasing the intensity of a message doesn’t always make it easier to understand. If the horse doesn’t have the information, balance, confidence, or physical capacity needed to respond, adding more pressure is probably only going to make the situation more difficult.
Effective communication requires us to respond to the entire conversation and consider what the learner is actually receiving, rather than focusing exclusively on what we believe we’re asking. We may need to explain something differently, break the task into smaller pieces, revisit a prerequisite, or simply give the horse a little more time to organize an appropriate response.
This definitely applies to teaching people just as much as it does to training horses. Our responsibility isn’t merely to deliver an instruction. It’s to help create the conditions in which that instruction can be understood, acted upon, and assimilated into a cumulative and ever-expanding experience.
The goal isn’t necessarily to ask more quietly or more loudly. It’s to become better at recognizing what kind of communication the situation actually requires.