11/06/2026
I saw a post by another trainer that said that absolutely under no circumstances is hitting a dog ever justified.
Needless to say, the comment section was full of agreement.
So what about this situation?
You're older and rehabbing perhaps a knee or hip replacement and out on a hiking trail.
Suddenly racing down the trail toward you is an exuberant young labrador off leash and it's owner yelling, because they have absolutely no control over the dog off leash, "don't worry, he's friendly!"
The enthusiastic dog arrives and starts jumping up on you, what exactly are you supposed to do to discourage that behaviour that might literally be putting you in danger of a fall?
What very frequently do other dogs do when other dogs interact with them inappropriately?
The problem with hitting your dog isn't actually hitting the dog. It's the mindset of the person doing that and very frequently it's frustration or anger.
Whether it's yanking on a leash, activating an electric collar or physically striking a dog, when those actions are based in the trainers emotional state, that's when there is a problem.
First and foremost, I'm not a punishment trainer. I'm a reinforcement trainer.
By in large I see physically striking a dog as punishment, although you could certainly find situations where it could be used as reinforcement.
Like so many things in dog training you need to be very, very self-aware and thoughtful and I see the great divide in training to generally be based in ideology.
Overwhelmingly but not entirely, I don't condone striking a dog, but I would never say that regardless of circumstances it's somehow morally abhorrent.
So much nuance and so much ideology.