19/10/2021
But dogs learn from each other using corrections so punishment and reinforcement is necessary for training dogs...
This is an argument I hear often. Consider this -
As a species we
Put and man on the moon
Invented the large hadron collider
Made the Rosetta space lander
Developed Vaccines
Understand germ theory
Built aeroplanes
Developed vehicles which travel at over 150 mph
and on and on
As individuals, the vast majority of us can
Run a household
Operate a computer
Make some sort of art
Tell stories
Plan for the future
Read, write, do complicated arithmetic
Order stuff online
And on and on
Do you know what else we can do? We can plan and think up training and learning protocols for our dogs which don't need the use of aversive training equipment. Yes, dogs use corrections with each other (although not nearly as much as some would have you believe) but ask yourself, out of the two lists above and all the other amazing things our species has achieved, can your dog do these things? They correct each other sometimes because they don't have other options. We do. Those options are not necessary for learning when we have a hand in the learning protocols. It's our own culture and learning history we need to change.
Love and peace.