31/08/2026
What happened to empathy and what that has to do with dogs.
This has been rolling around in my head for some time and a friend's comment on a recent post of mine has prompted me to put it into words. All it really takes is a quick scroll on the comments sections of social media to find evidence that it is disappearing at an alarming rate.
As humans lose the ability to empathise with others of our own species, it follows that we also lose the ability to empathise with other species. Being empathetic or compassionate is now branded as a weakness, as "woke", "soft" or my personal favourite - a "Loony Leftie". It's no coincidence that as empathy reduces, the number of dog professionals turning to aversive tools and outright abuse is increasing.
The thing is, the ability to empathise with others isn't just something you're either born with or not, it's a learned skill. Some people may have low empathy and a reduced capacity to develop it or express it, but they still have the capacity.
It had never occurred to me before that the rapid rise of division politics over the last 20 years, creating an "us Vs them" mentality, along with the oppositional style of social media with its outrage-led algorithms could affect our relationships with dogs, but it has. More people just want their dog's behaviour changed, no matter how and regardless of the emotional impact it has on the dog they share their lives with. People are becoming desensitised to animal abuse via viral videos of people using grot leads and shock collars to "correct" the even most insignificant behaviours and this, coupled with a lack of empathy isn't going to end well for dogs.
I don't like to bring politics onto this page, but when it is having an effect on how dogs (and other animals/wildlife) are treated, I will. I am a proud Loony Leftie, woke, force free dog person. This culture we have created of rejecting anything we perceive as different or "other", be it religion, ethnicity, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability (I could go on!) is eroding our ability to empathise. It's far easier to empathise with those similar to ourselves but other species are, by definition, very different, although they feel many of the same emotions we do. If as a society we are finding it hard to empathise with another person because of a perceived difference, we must be finding it even harder to empathise with animals.
Dog people spend hours debating aversive vs force free methods, but the problem itself can't be solved by debating because the problem is much deeper and is rooted in society as a whole. As we are pitted against each other we become defensive and search for a tribe to belong to. Perhaps we should look at the bigger picture to find the answers, look at ourselves honestly and ask whether our own ability to empathise is being slowly eroded. I recognised that in myself and made a conscious decision to do something about it.