09/04/2026
Medicating as a replacement for training
Something remarkable happened last week.
A local vet reached out to me asking to evaluate one of their client dogs. Due to certain training issues, the owner had chosen to keep their pet on anti-anxiety medications. This vet raised concern that medications were not a viable training strategy.
To say that I was pleasantly surprised is an understatement.
It is so, so common for vets to recommend medications as a replacement for training that I have already gotten used to the idea of segregation within the pet industry. Vets do their own thing, trainers do their own thing, and it is best that their worlds never collide. Collision tends to cause disagreements and conflicts.
In fact, my earlier post argued that vets should not make training recommendations, because unless they actually train dogs, they have no clue what they are talking about. This time was different, though, and I was genuinely impressed by someone's ability to recognize where the scope of their expertise ends and to refer a struggling owner elsewhere.
Why did medications become a stand-in for training? Good question. My best guess is that it is a by-product of a force-free cult, a group of people who believe in "ethical" training. This "ethics" follows human standards while often dismissing what it means for a dog.
As a consequence, many dogs fall through the cracks and are deemed untrainable. Once that happens, these dogs are often referred to vets who put them on perpetual medication. An absolute majority of these vets believe they are doing a kind and good thing. This is, of course, very questionable. At its core, the dilemma is this: show the dog that there are consequences for its actions, or avoid showing these consequences and cloud the dog's mind with medication so that it no longer knows what being a dog is. Put that way, the right answer seems simple. Apparently, it is not.
This is a very sad pattern to see. Some people question the medications route and come to me asking for advice. Many, however, are content to keep things as they are.
Seeing that at least one vet in the London area has the courage to do what is actually right felt like a breath of fresh air. There may be others. There is still hope that one day the worlds of veterinary medicine and dog training can actually intersect, and that something good may yet come out once that happens.
For anyone wondering who that vet was, feel free to ask in the comments. If I post it here, I am sure there will be attackers blaming me for making paid shoutouts :)