08/13/2026
I saw a ridiculous post from another breeder today claiming ribbons come at the expense of health, temperament, longevity, and adherence to the breed’s true purpose, and suggests that the “real” preservation breeders are the ones who prioritize the breed over success in the show ring.
There is a lot of romanticized nonsense in this, and the biggest problem is the false contrast it creates: as though you care about winning OR care about the breed.
Some of us have both.
You can love your breed deeply and want to win. In fact, I would argue that a serious preservation breeder should want their dogs evaluated and yes, want them to win. If you genuinely believe you have bred an outstanding representation of your breed, why would you not want it recognized?
👏🏻 A professional handler doesn’t mean a breeder doesn’t love their dogs.
👏🏻 Campaigning a dog doesn’t mean you don’t care what happens to it afterward.
👏🏻 A dog having a lot of titles doesn’t mean its breeder has neglected its pedigree, temperament, health or longevity.
👏🏻 Having a consistent breeding program isn’t something to be punished.
👏🏻 Bringing other pedigrees in isn’t something to be ashamed of. (Breeding yourself into a corner with high COIs and no ways to improve your program is.)
The most ridiculous part may be the implication that a breeder who wants to win is somehow less invested in their dogs than the person who wins less often.
We have old dogs, retired dogs, dogs who never finished and dogs who finished easily. We have dogs who are exceptional producers and dogs who we wouldn’t breed. We health test, study pedigrees and make difficult breeding decisions. We keep dogs because they belong to us, not because they are still “useful” and yes, we also enter shows because we believe our dogs are worthy of being there and because they win.
The purpose of the conformation ring is to identify dogs that best represent the written standard. Consistently producing dogs that are recognized as excellent examples of the breed is a good thing.
The answer isn’t to pretend winning doesn’t matter and to romanticize losing as being more virtuous. You don’t have to choose between loving the breed and wanting to win.
You can, AND SHOULD, want both.