10/18/2026
Why Not?
As humans we get in our own way about a lot of things. In all aspects of life I hear why things won't work but rarely do I hear a better idea or a different solution.
This is really common at work. Someone is given an assignment and they come back a day later to tell you that it isn't possible. Is it truly not possible or do they just not know how to do it? Almost all the time it is the later.
Why can't they accomplish what you want them to? This is a legit question.
One possibility is that they don't have enough experience to figure out the problem. If you gave me a calc problem it would likely not get done and I would give you the look Murphy used to give me when I was unclear about what I wanted. "I have no idea what I am doing and have no way of being successful."
Another possibility is that they don't want to ask for help. They are afraid that you will think less of them. Some think they are troubling you and others will simply struggle with the problem.
A third possibility is that they get online help but just repeat the steps given to them without understanding what they are doing. In the end the solution doesn't work but they don't know why it doesn't work and are stuck. AI is helpful if you know what you want to accomplish and come with broad guidelines to do it. Sometimes AI just eats up your time with no actual outcome because you can't communicate what you need to it.
There are multiple other possibilities but I will give one last one. People talk themselves out of their ability to accomplish the task. They get in their own heads and get overwhelmed. They over complicate or over simplify what they are trying to accomplish and when it doesn't work, they give up.
What about dogs? How do they problem solve? How do they attack a problem that you give them?
Well, that depends.
Penny would do something twice and if you asked her to do it a third time, she assumed what she did the first two times was wrong and she needed to find a new solution. It was mildly annoying that my dog was so much smarter than I was but her solution caused her trainer to only do things twice, move on to something else and come back to the exercise. Problem solved by Penny as most problems were, by her teaching you what to do.
Murphy on the other hand would just stop. When he didn't know what to do he would just stare at you and wait for something he understood or to guide him through what should happen. He needed to do something repeatedly to figure it out but once he did, he rarely missed it again at least if it was presented the same way to him.
Dog are like people in that they all learn a little differently. When I would hear field trainers talk about their "program" and how rigid they were in that program I knew we were in the wrong place.
It is the reason when people come and tell me "my dog is doing this, what do I do?" I have 30 questions that I need answered honestly or I need to be with the dog to watch what is happening.
I had a client with a Golden Retriever that didn't like their son. The dog was 3ish and the boy was 14 or so. What they described on the phone was the dog had just started acting out toward the boy and they had gotten concerned.
After I arrived we chatted for a bit. The boy was sitting with his legs over the dog and messing with the dog, poking, prodding and just being generally annoying. When the boy moved the dog could not get out of there fast enough, he truly disliked the boy or more so how the boy interacted with him. Because he was a Golden the people that that you could do anything to them and they would still love you and want to be around you. That is actually what they told me.
When the dog got up he ran straight to me and sat in front of me. I slide to the ground and petting him and watched what his terms for the interaction where. What he showed me is that he was not a dog that like to be held or cuddled and he sure didn't like to have someone basically sit on him.
We continued talking and soon the dog was laying on his back with his belly in the air and letting me pet him. He simply wanted a part in the decision making process as to how he was approached.
As soon as the boy moved towards him he ran downstairs and hid. He had gotten his point across that it was not okay the way he was treated.
It was a very long discussion with the people and boy afterwards, this was not what they really wanted in a dog, they wanted a dog that would hang out with their son, cuddle him in bed and be his wrestling buddy. Well, that ain't happening, I can promise you that.
We worked on some ways to gain trust. We played ball, we gave pets and treats for doing things well and most of all we respected the dog's space more than in the past. I called them a couple of days later and they said that they had to keep reminding their son of the rules and a week later they called me and told me the dog had actually brought a toy to their son to play tug with. It had finally clicked for all of them that the dog wasn't a thing, it was a being that had its own deal and was happy to share it with you if you stayed in the very reasonable guidelines.
This dog was far more like Murphy than Penny. He did the only thing he knew how, he growled a bit or ran away and hid. Once a bit of trust was brought into the equation he started to be much friendlier.
These folks recognized a problem, it was the wrong problem but they knew they needed a bit of help and then asked for it. Just like the folks at work that may have been in over their head when they realized that they needed a bit of help.
So the question is, what would Penny have done in the situation. She would have taught them what was okay and what was not. She was really good at giving human's lessons on what they were doing wrong. Murphy was just good at running away… fast.
-Dave
[Today's photo is of Murphy. He loved going with either of us, particularly if it was just him.]