10/15/2026
NYC Carriage Horse Ban-
As a lifelong horsewoman, registered Percheron breeder of 30 years, and carriage operator, it saddens me to see so much misinformation surrounding the proposed NYC carriage horse ban. Pulling a properly fitted carriage is not inherently abuse. Walking on pavement is not inherently abuse. Being outdoors in the sunshine is not inherently abuse. Like any horse, working horses deserve proper care, appropriate workloads, and responsible owners. Address legitimate welfare concerns with enforceable standards, not blanket bans.
These horses are privately owned, not city property, and when their owners lose their livelihoods, there is no guarantee every horse will find a suitable home. Horses are expensive to keep, and good intentions don't pay for hay, veterinary care, farriers, and facilities. After 30 years breeding Percherons, I've learned that even responsible breeders cannot control a horse's future after it's sold. I've personally seen horses I've raised end up in Canada because of soundness issues. Promising adoption is not the same as guaranteeing a lifetime of care.
I'm also deeply concerned about the future of the draft horse breeds. I've watched Percheron numbers decline throughout my years in the industry. These horses need a purpose and a market to encourage people to continue breeding, training, and preserving them. I believe we should hold bad actors accountable, but eliminating legitimate working opportunities has consequences that extend far beyond the city streets. If this ban is truly about protecting horses, then we must consider what happens to them afterward—not just celebrate the industry we're eliminating. After 30 years with these magnificent animals, I believe responsible ownership and meaningful welfare standards are a better path than assuming every horse will somehow find a perfect home.