23/10/2026
What makes a ‘good’ dog?
A question I’ve been thinking about a lot lately during clinical animal behaviour study.
Beyond established, dangerous or idiopathic behaviours, there’s those little quirky behaviours that show individuality. So, is it only obedience that denotes a ‘good dog’? What if they resource guard, for instance? Does that mean they are ‘naughty’ for taking your shoe and hiding it - or that it’s natural instinct, because it smells good to them/ keeps you with them etc?
We are honoured to have the trust of these wonderful animals, when domesticated. They trust and rely on us to survive; it’s just so good to try to understand their psychology a bit more. As a species that when treated fairly, stands by man, we are fortunate to have that opportunity.
So the answer? Through clinical learning I am realising that behaviourally it depends on so many factors, not least our human opinions: so I am sharing mine, to contribute to perspective, if it helps anyone, or any dog ❤️
A working dog will likely enjoy the challenge and focus of obedience training. A sniffer dog will likely enjoy the sniff and search element of their role and is bred for that. A family pet might like a walk, a routine and their favourite spot to sit in. It depends on the person, the relationship and the requirements as to what is seen as a ‘good’ dog.
Studies and behaviour theory show it’s also important to distinguish between the psychology of canine behaviour and the practical nature of canine obedience training - two distinct fields that work together, but are not to be confused (Strickler, 2018) Undoubtably all dogs need routine, care and to feel secure, but different dogs will have different needs. Really your expectations define what you class as ‘good’.
No animal is inherently ‘bad’ - we’re all just surviving: there’s usually a reason for behaviour seen by humans as ‘bad’ e.g. history, breed, health, genetics, learned behaviours, human expectations.
For myself (and many every day people) - where the dog’s mind is concerned - a happy dog, with a basic understanding of boundaries and commands, who gives joy and receives love, is a ‘good dog’… & a bit of character doesn’t go amiss! 😉🐾🐶
Ref: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cvsm.2017.12.008